For the working artist today, those who aspire to make their mark on the vertiginous world of modern art, it’s all about establishing “your own creative brand”…the essentials of the trade in the 2020s means having a social media presence (selling yourself on Instagram, Etsy, personal blog, etc), growing an audience online, creating a portfolio of your work, networking with fellow creatives, perhaps joining an artists’ collective, attending art events, parties, anything where you can market your “unique” creativity. The two 20th century Australian artists—Ian Fairweather and Arnold St Claire—who are the subjects of this piece would in no way conform to the above contemporary artist stereotype. The two were non-conformist in their “career” trajectories, each producing distinctive work from the standpoint of the outlier artist, far removed from the conventional pathway of the successful artist.
Painter of unique pub murals: Not much is known of Arnold St Claire’s early efforts in art, but by the mid-1960s the resident of Campbelltown on Sydney’s southwest fringe was making a minor ripple as a budding artist, having been a finalist in both the Sulman and the Archibald Prizes. St Claire’s forte was large-scale murals and watercolour paintings. Already, in his (brief) artistic career, St Claire was showing a tendency to veer towards the eccentric and the unexpected, in the late Sixties he held an art exhibition in a Gordon (NSW) butchers’ shop, exhibiting some 35 paintings on display, surrounded by hanging carcasses of fresh meat. The Australian Women’s Weekly magazine in an article of the day dubbed this unusual cultural juxtaposition, “Culture — Among the Cutlets!”

But it was in his mural work that St Claire found his true metier. The interior walls of hotels provided the canvas for a good deal of his art, like the Railway Hotel (now demolished), a local watering hole in Queen Street, Campbelltown. Another interesting series of the artist’s murals can be found in the bar of the Criterion Hotel in Gundagai, NSW. St Claire immortalised Gundagai’s greatest natural disaster—the Great Flood of 1852 which killed more than 80 residents and just about swept away the entire town—rendering it into the story of the famous biblical flood scenes painted by Michelangelo. St Claire replicated the exaggerated forms and contorted poses of the mural’s figures in the manner of the great Florentine master. Other walls in the bar are decorated with murals depicting 19th century bushrangers who were associated with Gundagai and its environs, such as Captain Moonlite. Payment for the Criterion artwork was in the form of “all-inclusive accommodation” (ie, food and drink in ample quantities for the visiting artist). Another St Claire project around this time was a commissioned Christmas religious mural which he painted on the facade of the Symond Shopping Arcade in suburban Strathfield.

St Claire turned his deft hand to sculpture as well. His best known work in the medium was a sculpture of epic proportions, a spectacular seven metre-high statue of a rearing horse ̷a̷ ̷. This colossal, three-tonne equine carving adorned the forecourt of the Tourmaline Hotel in Vineyard (NSW), becoming something of an iconic landmark in the local district. St Claire created this free-standing sculpture as a gift for a Hawkesbury horse trainer friend of his (later the statue disappeared, current whereabouts unknown).

Though widely popular with people—considered by his acquaintances to have been quite a “wag”—St Claire was increasingly afflicted by the diseases of alcoholism and mental illness. Sometimes, out of such adversity, from harrowing personal experience, comes the lucidity to create something exceptional𖤓. In St Claire’s disturbing experience it seems to have prompted the realisation of the artist’s magnum opus. Admitted to the Parramatta Psychiatric Centre (now Cumberland Hospital East), patient St Claire painted a series of epic murals, floor-to-ceiling, on all four walls of Ward 8 (completed in 1971–72). These are murals of stunning originality, replete with bold colours and vivid imagery. The subject matter ranges from images of eastern religions and mythology from different cultures including Australian Aborigines to selected scenes from history ̷̷b̷ ̷.

⇧ Cumberland Hospital “Mural Room” ⇩

Arnold St Claire’s talent for art and his life was tragically cut short…the troubled Sydney artist was one of many patients subjected to the controversial “deep sleep” therapy notoriously and fatally administered by medical practitioners at Chelmsford Private Hospital, subsequently dying of pneumonia at Hornsby Hospital in 1974, still only in his forties.

♠ ♠ ♠ ♠ ♠ ♠
xxxxxxxx
The bush hermit artist of Bribie Island: Ian Fairweather’s life journey took a different turn to that of St Claire’s, in fact it took many different turns ̷c̷ ̷. Born in Scotland, for the first two-thirds of his life the restless Fairweather had a peripatetic existence, roaming from one country to another across the globe. Wherever Fairweather stayed, he painted…profoundly influenced by Chinese calligraphy, several of the Mandarin-speaking Sinophile’s 1930s paintings done in China are among his best. Despite the dislocating lifestyle of constantly moving and not taking root in any one place, Fairweather still managed to do business, arranging for the exhibition (and sale) of his paintings in London (Tate) and in Australia (Macquarie Galleries).

The expat Scot finally anchored himself down on Bribie Island (S/E Queensland) for good…it was here that nomad Fairweather transformed into hermit Fairweather. The reclusive artist settled into a minimalist lifestyle for which he would become famous, both within Australia and abroad. The eccentric and often cantankerous artist constructed a rough, no-frills grass hut for his living quarters and pursued a spartan, frugal life in isolation, shunning crowds and publicity. For art materials, he scrounged together items wherever he could find them – cardboard, newspaper, toothpaste, (inferior-quality) house paint and the like.

From early in his career Fairweather started to use gouache ̷𝓭 ̷ paint—sometimes mixed with watercolour—a change prompted by discovering that he was allergic to oils. ‘Nutmeg sifters (Singapore)’ (ca.1941) is instructive in demonstrating this quality of opaqueness in his paintings, often applied to fragile or unstable surfaces (in this case, to thin cream tissue). This unorthodox method was very much the norm for Fairweather, in fact, in his entire career he only ever completed four works on canvas – in the 1920s.

Fairweather developed a painting style that referenced a smorgasbord of diverse cultural influences. The early inspiration from European cubism and abstraction was fused together with later influences gleaned from his extensive travels – including Chinese, southeast Asian, Aboriginal and Oceanic art. Increasingly, Fairweather’s compositions veered towards the abstract, the apotheosis of which is probably his 1958 painting ‘War and Peace’ with its layer upon layer of thick brush strokes, considered a work of “full Monty” abstract expressionism (usually though, in his abstract works Fairweather preferred to retain a human element in the painting).

Fairweather spent his final 21 years in the seclusion of his disorderly and bare-basic Bribie Island hut, mostly productively churning out paintings until illness precluded his capacity to paint. A measure of fame (and some decent renumeration) did come Fairweather’s way but characteristically the bush hermit artist seemed to remain indifferent to it. Almost immediately after he died—the same year as St Claire, 1974—the local council moved with indecent haste to burn the famous artist–recluse’s grass hut home.


𖤓 this is commonly labelled “tortured artist syndrome”, a widely ascribed theory which purports that great creativity/an artist’s best work occurs when he or she is in the grips of mental anguish or suffering
̷a̷ ̷ modelled on the conformation of a champion racehorse, King Tourmaline
̷b̷ ̷ in 1989 the then medical superintendent at the hospital wanted to whitewash St Claire’s unique mural room paintings but after the staff protested on mass, he relented
̷c̷ ̷ including service in both world wars – with an ironic twist: in WWI Fairweather spent almost the entire war as a POW of the Germans, whereas for a good portion of WWII he was O-I-C of a POW camp for Italian prisoners!
̷𝓭 ̷ a method of painting opaque pigments ground in water and thickened with a glue-like substance
🎨. 🎨 🎨
‘Arnold St Claire’, The History Buff, 12-Dec-2017, http://campbelltown-library.blogspot.com
‘175 Years of Mental Health – Episode 3: The Artist and the Mural, Arnold St Claire’, Western Sydney Health, (Video, 2024), www.youtube.com
‘Ian Fairweather’, Art Gallery of NSW, www.artgallery.nsw.gov.au
Janet Hogan, ‘Fairweather, Ian (1891–1974)’, Australian Dictionary of Biography, National Centre of Biography, Australian National University, https://adb.anu.edu.au/biography/fairweather-ian-10147/text17919, published first in hardcopy 1996, accessed online 9 June 2025.